A Cover for My New Critique Group

After my previous critique group disbanded, I began a search for some fellow MG writers to give my manuscripts one more look through. It didn’t take long to find three ladies desperately seeking (my words, not theirs) an MG writer.

I wasn’t sure at first since they were an Adult, YA, and a Picture Book writer, all sporting new works ready to be critiqued: A 120,000 word Historical Fiction, two separate YA contemporary offerings, and two picture books. They’d been together for several years and preferred having the various levels in their group to get a broader scope of opinions. I went ahead and signed on as the newbie.

They are spread around the country so my monthly writer’s group meeting (with to die for snacks)  is no more. Anyway, I couldn’t wait to get started and send the first chapters of two stories that have been revised again, but it seems like the final push as they’ve been critiqued to the max. My instructions came the next day with directions to send a sample book cover for each story. Huh? Was I in the wrong group?

I soon found out this was how they start their critique process, to see how you might interpret a front cover for your story. “Interesting,” I said. “I’ll get back to you on that one.”

I thought about book covers I adore, mostly the simple ones that provide just a hint as to what lies ahead. I don’t like dark covers where details are hard to decipher or busy covers with so much going on my head is spinning. I sifted through some of my favorites:


  1. THE WEDNESDAY WARS provides a window to the main character with his desk slightly tilted. And what’s with the rodent?  This one grabbed me right away.
  2. LIAR AND SPY is a simple cover that says a lot. The title of course, but also the calming blue colors with the one light shining in the top room. So intriguing.
  3. DEAD END IN NORVELT is sadly hilarious. The boy’s head covered by the dead end sign, and how will that plane be a part of the story?

So I went to work on my first cover. It was rather an amazing process, thinking about my story as a whole and trying to capture a new reader’s attention in a single cover. It also made the story feel more complete.  I could see this taking a good portion of August so I kept it simple.  I’m just glad I don’t design book covers for a living. I’ll stick to writing and leave the covers to professionals.


About Greg Pattridge

Climbing another mountain...always striving to reach the next peak in my life and career.
This entry was posted in Critiques and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to A Cover for My New Critique Group

  1. Kevin Gerard says:

    Hi Greg,

    I like that cover – seems like that kid’s never gotten one present he liked 😦

    If your new critique group is looking for a 58 year old / 10 year old writer I’d love to explore a different avenue. I’ve been with my group for years. Great folks, but I think we getting used to each other’s stories.

    Let me know — ..


    • I always feel closer in age to my 10-year-old self! As for the new critique group it’s a wait and see. If they work out I’ll see if they’d like another writer. So far all I have are their covers and no feedback.

  2. Actually that is a good idea for a cover. I like that they ask you to submit a cover, because it helps you think more visually. Hope you enjoy the new critique group.

  3. What a great exercise. I think it’s a good idea — kind of like a visual log line. Good luck with your new group. It’s always fun and a little scary to start with a new group.

  4. super cute and such a fun thing to do. Best of luck with the new group!

  5. Andrea says:

    Interesting exercise! Though if it was me I’d spend hours perfecting the “imaginary” cover instead of writing. (Okay, so I get easily distracted.)

    I like your cover!

  6. Intriguing crit group exercise that I think I’ll share with my group. Thanks!

Place your thoughts here with a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.