CHASING SECRETS for Marvelous Middle Grade Monday

There are two reasons why this ended up on my books to read list last year. First was the author, Gennifer Choldenko. I had fondly remembered reading one of her other novels, AL CAPONE DOES MY SHIRTS, the story of Moose Flanagan and his family’s life on Alcatraz Island.

The second reason was not the cover or the title, but instead the sub-title or logline for the book: A DEADLY SURPRISE IN A CITY OF LIES. There is so much mystery and intrigue in those eight words. Yes, I waited too long to enjoy this author again, especially with this journey back to 1900 San Francisco.51MTBA-t9-L._SX326_BO1,204,203,200_

Narrated by Lizzie, a spunky 13-year-0ld who doesn’t fit in with expectations that girls are trained for future lives as wives, her voice shines throughout. Front and center though is the Bubonic Plague and Lizzie’s attempts to understand its ramifications through her older brother, her father, and a Chinese boy she befriends. This clash of race and culture is not acceptable  and Lizzie and Noah must be careful when and where they meet.

The pacing is excellent and the 36 chapters fly by like the wind. You know this is going to be a sad tale, but with doses of humor and a coming of age innocence, I hope you will add this one to your list.


FULL PLOT (From AMAZON) San Francisco, 1900. The Gilded Age. A fantastic time to be alive for lots of people . . . but not thirteen-year-old Lizzie Kennedy, stuck at Miss Barstow’s snobby school for girls. Lizzie’s secret passion is science, an unsuitable subject for finishing-school girls. Lizzie lives to go on house calls with her physician father. On those visits to his patients, she discovers a hidden dark side of the city—a side that’s full of secrets, rats, and rumors of the plague.
The newspapers, her powerful uncle, and her beloved papa all deny that the plague has reached San Francisco. So why is the heart of the city under quarantine? Why are angry mobs trying to burn Chinatown to the ground? Why is Noah, the Chinese cook’s son, suddenly making Lizzie question everything she has known to be true? Ignoring the rules of race and class, Lizzie and Noah must put the pieces together in a heart-stopping race to save the people they love.


  1. The author notes are rich with more information about the plague, Chinatown, and medical insights during that time period. Many more secrets are revealed here.
  2. Issues of racism, immigration, and discrimination are set forth for young readers in an understandable way and make way for comparisons to today’s world. Excellent discussion starter.
  3. History doesn’t have to be boring! This little known historical event is presented through a fascinating series of events. Some funny, many more heart wrenching.
  4. Lizzie is a strong female character we can cheer for. She questions even the brightest minds about the inconsistencies in medicine and in her relationships with family and hired help. Lizzie tries  to shape her own world view.
  5. Like today and 116 years ago, money often gets in the way of good decisions. It was nice to have a story that framed this theme so perfectly.

FAVORITE LINES:(A conversation between Lizzie and Noah)

“You think I’m stupid?”

“You’re not as smart as I am.”

“What? That’s not a nice thing to say. How would you know, anyway?”

“You’re a girl. You’ll get married, like all girls do.”

“I’m not getting married.” The flush rises in my cheeks. “Wives have to do what they’re told.”

“Maybe you could marry a stupid husband, and then you could make all the decisions.”

I frown. “What would I do with a stupid husband?”

“If you got tired of him, you could take him to the auction.”

“A stupid-husband auction?” I ask. “Would the amount of money you got for him be based on how stupid he was?”

AUTHOR QUOTE (From Gennifer Choldenko’s web site:  I am the youngest child in a large, loud family. We are so loud, in fact, that strangers sometimes asked us if our parents were deaf.


Make a comment below if you have time. I enjoy reading all of them.

Check the links to other Middle Grade novels over at Shannon Messenger’s Marvelous Middle Grade Monday post.


About Greg Pattridge

Climbing another mountain...always striving to reach the next peak in my life and career.
This entry was posted in Reviews and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to CHASING SECRETS for Marvelous Middle Grade Monday

  1. This book sounds great! I especially liked the lines you picked out for us. They’re hilarious. It sounds like this book could help us learn history? I wouldn’t mind that! 🙂 Thanks for the review!

  2. Wow! That’s an amazing logline that draws me in too. Sounds like a fantastic story.

  3. Violet Tiger says:

    Sounds really good. Thanks for the review!

  4. Great review! You have me intrigued on this story. My library has a copy! Thanks!

  5. Wonderful review, Greg. I agree this book is a great one and deserves wide readership. I was surprised when I saw the word count. It seemed much shorter to me. As you said, it flew by. Thanks for reminding me of this wonderful book.

  6. cleemckenzie says:

    I love her books, so this one’s going to find a home with me. Thanks

  7. diegosdragon says:

    I think my wife might find a place for me in the stupid husband auction 🙂

  8. warrchick says:

    I am so intrigued! This story sounds amazing–worth even the sad parts. 😉 Thanks for the recommend, and happy MMGM!


  9. Andrea Mack says:

    This one sounds intriguing! I love books that take place in an earlier time and I enjoyed the “Al Capone” books. Definitely going to look for this one.

  10. Pingback: AL CAPONE THROWS ME A CURVE | Always in the Middle…

Place your thoughts here with a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.