First off, I have a love/hate reaction with the cover. Scholastic knows their marketing in that kids (and many big kids) love a good story about animals. The dog and cat are cute, (that’s why I picked it off the shelf) and there’s a similar cute image on the back. The problem I have is that the obvious ploy to sell this book slightly misrepresents what the book is about.
Stare at the cover and see if you agree. My first reaction: It’s a tale of two pets in one house or in a neighborhood fighting for dominance. Maybe even told from the dog and cat’s view point. I’m not much for talking animals so I started to put the book back on the shelf. Before it got there I decided to read the first page and discovered it was about Otto, an eleven-year-old dog lover, and the sibling rivalry with his 12-year-old sister, Lexi, a cat lover. They have no pets in their house so the slightly overwhelmed mom decides to accept Lexi’s idea for a contest–whoever first earns $500 in one month, is rewarded with the pet of their choosing. I would have put the two main characters on the cover with one eye on each other and the other on the prize–a dog or cat staring at them through the pet shelter’s window. It’s a story about sibling rivalry, responsibility, and goal setting rather than two animals in a face-off… Okay, I’m done ranting about cute covers, especially since this one caused me to read the book in the first place. Besides, I actually love Alan Woodrow’s tale, though it would have been just as good, maybe better, at 45,000 words.
PUBLICATION DATE:2013 LEVEL: 3.8 WORD COUNT: 54,663
FULL PLOT (From Amazon): THE PET WAR is a hilarious story about the timeless battles of dog vs. cat, brother vs. sister, know-it-all vs. know-nothing.
Eleven-year-old Otto wants a dog. His twelve-year-old perfect sister, Lexi, wants a cat. Their mother, who works very long hours as a nurse, wants neither. Pets are expensive so who’s going to pay for everything? And what happens to the pet when the siblings are at their dad’s for the weekend?
Otto has an idea. What if he got a job and earned enough money to pay for the dog? Then Lexi has to open her big mouth. She proposes that whichever sibling can raise enough money first will decide which pet they get. Oddly enough, their mom and dad agree.
With Otto and Lexi each out to defeat the other, their business plans become more elaborate and involved. As the competition gets fiercer, the stakes get higher, and the battle lines have been drawn, so let the Pet War begin. . . .
FIVE THINGS TO LIKE ABOUT THE PET WAR
- The story is told by Otto and each chapter heading begins with his summary of the amount of money he has earned toward the $500 goal. These snippets tell a story all their own.
- The way Otto goes about thinking up new schemes to earn money. Most end in hilarious ways.
- Boys will especially love the inventive name calling and the “I can top that one” mentality that goes on between Otto and his best friend, and Otto and his sister: “You’re a mulch-breathing hamster-eating vomit brain swimming in stink!” puts one such argument to an end, and you’ll never read that line in any other book.
- The subtle way divorce is handled in this family. It’s a way of life for Otto and Lexi who stay connected to both their mom and dad. They aren’t crazy about the set-up, but accept the situation like so many other kids their age.
- Otto’s continuous narrative about the world: Lunch room pizza, his own safety, baking cookies, handicap spaces, and much more all get his kid’s view of why things turn out the way they are. I could see a companion booklet coming out called, Otto’s Realistic Take on the World.
It’s hard to pretend you’re twenty-two when you’re walking a bike and you’re about eight years away from shaving.
Check the links to other Middle Grade novels over at Shannon Messenger’s Marvelous Middle Grade Monday post.
I hadn’t thought about the cover being deceiving. This has been a big hit with my reluctant readers, so they do pick it up, but they seem to be finishing it as well. I thought it was light and breezy and would like to see more by this author!
Your thoughts on the cover are interesting and maybe a better fit for the story, but Karen’s comment above is also interesting.
Great cover rant, Greg!
I would have bought the book for the “hamster-eating vomit brain” line alone.
I never would have given this book a second look because of the cover. Thanks for telling me about it. It sounds like a lot of fun.
Interesting thoughts on the cover! This is one that is on my to read list. Looking forward to reading it, maybe should move it on up so I could get it read sooner!
Pingback: Do Dads Get a Fair Look in MG Books? | Always in the Middle
Pingback: Ten Favorite Summertime Middle Grade Reads | Always in the Middle
Pingback: CYBILS Public Nominations Announced | Always in the Middle