I’m off and running into my sixth year at ALWAYS in the MIDDLE. The winners of my Anniversary Giveaway of a book and gift card are:
KATHLEEN BURKINSHAW (I LOVE YOU, MICHAEL COLLINS)
ROSI HOLLINBECK (MOON SHADOW)
MICHAEL GETTEL-GILMARTIN (POSTED)
DONNA FRANCZEK (WELCOME TO WONDERLAND #2)
Congratulations to all. And now onto this weeks review…
************************************************************************
I’ve never come across an editor requesting more prison dramas for middle grade. But here we have the second one in two years with THE WARDEN’S DAUGHTER. Last year I featured ALL RISE FOR THE HONORABLE PERRY T. COOK, the story of a boy born and raised for his first eleven years in a prison where his mother is incarcerated for a crime Perry doesn’t understand.
All Rise For The Honorable Perry T. Cook is a book I’d share with middle grade readers of all ages. It has a heartwarming beat in the face of desperation. I also liked THE WARDEN”S DAUGHTER but not as a middle grade reader. I felt the adult side of me clinging to the pages and would be hesitant to recommend it to children under 13.
The narration is through the eyes of Cammie as an adult looking back on the summer when she was about to celebrate her 13th birthday. Yes, back then she lived with her dad in an upstairs apartment in Pennsylvania’s Hancock County Prison. It’s 1959 and she mingles with the female prisoners in the exercise yard and longs to have a mother. Her own mom was killed, run over by a car while walking Cammie’s baby carriage across the street. Cammie survived but is in a downward spiral of depression.
There’s a murder, a suicide, and underage cigarette smoking that teachers and parents should be aware of before having the younger ones dive in to the pages. The writing is stellar and I’d take this on a long trip to enjoy before handing it off to another adult reader. It’s the best middle grade book for older readers I’ve read this year. Not so much for the 10-year-olds.
PUBLICATION DATE: 2017 PAGE COUNT: 352
FULL PLOT (From AMAZON) Cammie O’Reilly lives at the Hancock County Prison–not as a prisoner, she’s the warden’s daughter. She spends the mornings hanging out with shoplifters and reformed arsonists in the women’s exercise yard, which gives Cammie a certain cache with her school friends.
But even though Cammie’s free to leave the prison, she’s still stuck. And sad, and really mad. Her mother died saving her from harm when she was just a baby. You wouldn’t think you could miss something you never had, but on the eve of her thirteenth birthday, the thing Cammie most wants is a mom. A prison might not be the best place to search for a mother, but Cammie is determined and she’s willing to work with what she’s got.
FIVE THINGS TO LIKE ABOUT: THE WARDEN’S DAUGHTER by Jerry Spinelli
- You get a smidgen of how life was like in 1959 and a sidelight with American Bandstand and its popularity with kids.
- I often wonder how young characters in books would emerge in adult life. My question about Cammie is answered in the final chapter written by adult Cammie in 2017.
- It’s estimated that an average of one child in every classroom has an incarcerated parent so books like this one could connect in a positive way.
- The secondary characters like Eloda, young Andrew, Reggie and Danny were characters I wanted to get to know better. They were bright spots to cover the unlikable qualities of Cammie.
- A positive ending brought a smile back to my face.
FAVORITE LINES: Now, in the weeks after Mother’s Day, something was changing. Enough was no longer enough. Dormant feelings stirred by a smile at a ballpark moved and shifted until they shaped a thought: I was sick and tired of being motherless.
I wanted one. And a second thought: If I couldn’t have my first-string mother, I’d bring one in off the bench.
But who?
A teacher?
The next lady who smiled at me?
The flash point came in five words.
A FEW RECENT WORDS from Jerry Spinelli:
********************************************************************
Make a comment if you have time. I enjoy reading all of them. Click on the comments link below.
Check the links to other Middle Grade novels over at Shannon Messenger’s Marvelous Middle Grade Monday post.


in some way to mythical creatures. A dream sends him off to discover the meaning and he gets a brief first meeting with the majestic gryphon known as Phylassos—part lion-part eagle.




This last event is the focus for this new book, but it’s not about Neil Armstrong. It’s about the man who was left behind to orbit the moon while his two comrades received the glory of being the first. Mention the name Neil Armstrong or Buzz Aldrin and many will recognize the names. Michael Collins? Not so much.
to expect:
MAKE ‘EM LAUGH. AND LAUGH AGAIN.
duty 300+ page middle grade monstrosities. A story about Jim Murphy’s sixth grade year at St. Stephen’s Elementary School in 1958 Kearny, New Jersey was the perfect remedy.

another MG mini-drama filled with divorce, broken friendships, and confused feelings. But wait…a bit of magic saved the day.

